Deputy Leader of the Labour Party calls for social media bosses to be locked up

05 Apr 2019

Tom Watson, Deputy Leader of the Labour Party speaking to BBC Radio 4’s flagship news programme (05.04.19) called for “unaccountable” social media giants to be broken up and for their executives to suffer criminal sanction.

Speaking to Today’s Nick Robinson, Watson described Facebook as too big to be regulated and called for other social media giants to be broken up under competition law.  He condemned the live streaming of the New Zealand murders on the 15th March.  In the meantime, yesterday Mark Zuckerberg was reported by CNN as saying Facebook would not delay livestreams after last month’s massacre. 

There is power under the UK Competition Act 1998 to accept commitments from an organisation that has been found to have abused its market power.  These commitments may include the breaking up (divestment) of all or part of that organisation.  The Competition and Markets Authority has power to give Directions to infringing organisations to cease the infringing behaviour, but the competition regime in the United States is far more explicit in terms of the power by US regulators to order the break-up of market dominant organisations. 

What is being considered now in the UK are powers more explicitly along the lines of the US law.  Mr Watkins goes further and calls for criminal sanction against executives of firms that permit the uploading of racist, hate and offensive material. 

I would make this point: social media platforms have billions of users - Facebook alone has 2.3 billion users. So we must ask two questions of ourselves: 

  • Firstly, do we trust government and its regulators to regulate cyberspace?
  • Secondly (to be asked only if the answer to the first is in the affirmative) is – OK, well how?

Hard cases make bad law; a cliché, yes, but like all clichés it has a grain of truth.

We have seen how social media platforms have permitted live streaming of shootings.  We have seen how material on taking one’s own life has contributed to people doing just that.  We have seen material on everything from eating disorders to ISIS to material from the far right.

I accept all that, and I accept that social media can hurt.  But I urge caution.  There is much of merit on social media platforms.  I argue that it is difficult for platforms to self regulate because of the ease with which material can be uploaded; I do not see how regulation will ease those difficulties.  How do you regulate material from 2.3 billion potential uploaders?  

Be reasonable

The regulatory regime must be limited to the platform taking reasonable steps to prevent material being uploaded, and reasonable efforts to remove it once the platform becomes or is made aware of the material concerned.  But isn’t that, in reality, what is happening now?

Further, if we decide to break up the larger platforms, will we not be multiplying the problem rather than solving it?

I don’t see what locking up executives will achieve either.  To impose criminal liability in such cases where the criminal is surely the person who uploads the material is just not fair.  The chances of conviction will be limited.

So let us not rush to the law book before we have really thought about this; whatever the ‘popular press’ may say, lawmakers must take some time to think.

Further reading

Commercial landlords face extended restrictions

Blog, Legal Updates
Landlords take another hit as tenants’ protection mandated to last two years; Lawrence Morley takes a look
Read more Read

New Homes Quality Code – consultation under way

Blog, Legal Updates
Now is the time for housing developers to contribute to the discussion about new quality code
Read more Read

Is changing terms of employment about to become more difficult?

Employers beware. It may become more difficult to change terms of employment through the process of dismissal and re-engagement or “fire and rehire”.
Read more Read

Is the menopause really a business issue?

Abigail Maino explores the extent to which employers should be supporting employees who may be struggling with symptoms of the menopause
Read more Read
  • Brighton Office

    1 Jubilee Street


    East Sussex

    BN1 1GE

  • Gatwick Office

    Griffin House

    135 High Street


    West Sussex

    RH10 1DQ

  • Guildford Office

    Wonersh House

    The Guildway

    Old Portsmouth Road



    GU3 1LR

  • Horsham Office

    Ridgeland House

    15 Carfax


    West Sussex

    RH12 1DY

  • London Office

    6 New Street Square

    New Fetter Lane


    EC4A 3BF

  • Get in touch