What is the potential effect of the Green Agenda on property disputes?

14 Dec 2021

The Green Agenda is inevitably going to have an effect on property disputes going forward, and will certainly have a role to play in the settlement of future dilapidations claims. As existing leases of buildings end, it may well be the only opportunity for landlords to improve the green credentials of those buildings. It will also become more difficult, politically, for landlords to justify at lease end the ripping out and throwing away of kit and fit out which has not reached the end of its economic life. Perhaps even “ end of economic life” will take on a new meaning as we are encouraged to upcycle, recycle, and reduce carbon emissions.
As such, the often held assumption that landlords will insist on their tenants undertaking wholesale reinstatement as part of a dilapidation claim may need to be debunked. Such insistence might even become a reputational issue for landlords. Incoming tenants themselves may start choosing to not be associated with newly fitted out buildings but rather look for buildings that are selling themselves as reusing what is already there. 
These changing attitudes to reinstatement at lease end could provide tenants with the means of reducing landlords' dilapidation claims. If landlords are looking to recover damages to compensate for costs of works that the tenant did not complete, the measure of those costs is not about the individual landlord. Instead, it is about what the reasonable costs for reasonable works that it is reasonable to carry out are. It is an objective test and may be judged against a landlord with carbon reduction targets and even one who embraces a circular economy principle. We can expect tenants to raise this argument  as a defence to some claims. We can also expect arguments of supersession. 
With the MEES regulations requiring higher standards for buildings, and landlords having  their own published sustainability policies, tenants will be looking at the works necessary to meet these targets, and assessing when it is going to be possible for landlords to carry out the necessary works. Some will then defend dilapidations claims on the basis that tenant works carried out at lease end would be superseded.

Read our other predictions for 2022

Further reading

I was divorced overseas, will my divorce be recognised in England and Wales?

A divorce carried out in one country may not always be recognised in another. Gemma Garrett discusses the often complex issue of foreign divorce recognition
Read more Read

VAT and break options in commercial leases

In September 2020, HMRC updated its guidance on payments arising out of early contract termination, pending further review. Cheraine Williams comments on what we can expect to see in further promised guidance updates
Read more Read

HM Treasury confirms certain cryptoassets will be regulated by the Finance Promotion Regime

Blog, Legal Updates
The government has confirmed that the scope of the Financial Promotion Order 2005 will be expanded to bring certain cryptoassets within its remit. Read more about the proposed amendments.
Read more Read

Service charge demands – getting it right

Cheraine Williams details the importance of checking your lease and offers her advice to avoid painful Court applications
Read more Read
  • Brighton Office

    1 Jubilee Street


    East Sussex

    BN1 1GE

  • Gatwick Office

    Griffin House

    135 High Street


    West Sussex

    RH10 1DQ

  • Guildford Office

    Wonersh House

    The Guildway

    Old Portsmouth Road



    GU3 1LR

  • Horsham Office

    Ridgeland House

    15 Carfax


    West Sussex

    RH12 1DY

  • London Office

    6 New Street Square

    New Fetter Lane


    EC4A 3BF

  • Get in touch