REAL ESTATE DISPUTE RESOLUTION

VAT and break termination payments – recent ruling goes against tenants

The recent decision in Vengtrove Ltd v Kuene Nagel Ltd [2022] means tenants should be extra diligent when exercising any break clauses in their leases which involve termination payments and ensure that any VAT is paid thereon if there is an option to tax in place.

The latest decision in the case, which was heard in the Inner House of the Court of Session in Scotland, is an appeal from an earlier decision whereby the Judge had ruled that VAT was not due on break clause termination payments despite the wording in the lease and an option to tax.

The latest decision reverses that. On appeal, the Court and has now concluded VAT was due on the break clause termination payment and the break clause here had not been validly exercised as a result. The tenant is now running an estoppel argument, essentially seeking to debar the landlord from insisting the break was not effective. There will be another hearing but, for now, essentially, VAT would not normally be due on a break clause termination payment in a break clause unless there is an option to tax in place and, if there is, VAT should be paid.

Tenants should be checking any break clause carefully and, if it includes a termination payment and the property has an option to tax, the tenant should seek specialist VAT advice on the current position. However, if that is not an option, the safest route would be to pay the VAT and argue about it later.

The payment could be taken towards dilapidations by the landlord but, of course, there is a risk of never getting that money back if the landlord enters into any insolvency regime. However, by paying it over it will limit any argument that the break clause has not been validly exercised due to non-payment of VAT and the lease continuing (subject to compliance with any other break conditions).

Landlords should also be carefully checking a tenant’s strict compliance with any break clause too. Be careful not to inadvertently waive compliance with any break conditions if they are keen for the tenant to remain in the premises, for example, if they would find it difficult to re-let the property.

If you need help in understanding the potential pitfalls in your break clause, please contact a member of the team on 03333 231 580 or email enquiries@dmhstallard.com

About the authors


about the author img

Cheraine Williams

Senior Associate

Expert in property and construction disputes, in addition to property related insolvency issues and agricultural tenancies.

Stay connected, sign up for updates

Stay connected

Recent articles

Media spotlight

Impending passing of the Renters (Reform) Bill spells trouble for tenants and landlords

Ian Narbeth shares his insights with Property118 on the potential impact of the Renters (Reform) Bill  for tenants and landlords

Ian Narbeth

17/05/2024

Events

Property and Planning breakfast seminar, Brighton, June 2024

Network with colleagues in the field over bacon rolls before hearing the latest news from our team.

15/05/2024

Events

Property and Planning breakfast seminar, Crawley, June 2024

Join our expert Real Estate and Planning teams in Crawley  as we bring you the latest updates in Property law and answer your questions.

14/05/2024

Media spotlight

DMH Stallard noted as one of the best firms for championing women

legalbusiness.co.uk writes about the number of female professionals ranked in leading legal directory Legal500, with DMH Stallard holding 14 rankings across 20+ departments in the latest edition.

11/03/2024