Reducing risk in commercial property disputes for business owners

Business owners can reduce the risk of commercial property disputes by ensuring that all lease and contract terms are clearly drafted, reviewed by legal professionals and fully understood before signing.  Clear documentation, addressing any issues that arise promptly and early legal advice from a commercial property solicitor are key to managing risk and avoiding costly litigation.

Discover more about

Terminating your lease – break notices

Terminating a commercial lease using a break notice can offer valuable flexibility but it also carries legal and financial risks. Errors in serving the notice or failing to meet the break clause conditions can leave tenants facing costly bills.

  • A contractual right to terminate a lease can be a useful option but it requires careful consideration.
  • If the break clause is not exercised properly then the lease will continue, which could have disastrous consequences for you or your business.
  • Break clauses often require various conditions to be met following service of the break notice. Failure to meet just one of those conditions could lead to a lease not terminating.
  • The Courts require strict compliance with break clauses.
  • Our commercial property dispute solicitors often advise clients on the exercise of a break clause to help manage the risks and can help:
    • advise you on what needs to be done in order to exercise the break clause;
    • advise you on the consequences of serving a break notice;
    • draft and handle the service of a notice on your behalf;
    • advise you on the steps to take to comply with the break clause conditions; and
    • advise you on the related steps you would need to consider when the lease ends, such as dilapidations liabilities.

Top Tip

Careful planning and legal review are essential to avoid unintended consequences.

Vacating your premises? Plan your exit

Vacating your premises requires careful planning to avoid costs or unexpected legal issues. Whether triggered by growth, downsizing, or a change in strategy a well-managed exit involves reviewing lease obligations notice periods and dilapidations.

  • If you are a tenant which is moving your business from one property to another it can be a stressful process, with lots to consider. It can be easy to overlook the obligations you owe under your lease and in some cases, this could lead to expensive financial consequences.
  • If you are a landlord and your tenant is vacating, this can also be a testing time as you will be seeking to hold your outgoing tenant to their obligations under the lease while lining up a new tenant to move in without too much of a rental void.
  • The single largest issue that you will have to deal with is likely to be dilapidations by which we mean a tenant’s liability to leave the property in the correct state of repair, decoration, condition and layout.
  • A Lease and/or Licence to Alter will often set out whether a tenant is obliged to reinstate the property by removing alterations which it has made, such as partitioning. Sometimes, the obligation will depend on the landlord first triggering it, or it might apply automatically.

Top Tip

Whether you are a landlord or a tenant, it is often sensible to seek advice at an early stage from a commercial property solicitor and a building surveyor on the extent of the potential claim, your options for addressing it and any deadlines which apply to contractual provisions, such as reinstatement obligations.

Renewing a business lease – notices and deadlines

Renewing a business lease involves more that just agreeing new terms, it is a time sensitive process governed by strict legal rules. Missing key notice periods or deadlines can weaken your negotiating position or even cost you your right to renew.

  • The Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 (“the Act”) governs the statutory process which applies to the renewal of leases of business premises in cases where the lease has not been contracted out. A link to our short briefing note about the Act can be found here.
  • If you are a tenant who is considering whether to renew its lease then it is important to take advice on your options at an early stage.
  • You might be a landlord which is either considering offering its tenant a new lease or perhaps looking to regain possession so that the building can be redeveloped, for example.
  • The Act entitles a landlord and a tenant to serve a notice if they want to commence the statutory lease renewal process or oppose it (in the case of a landlord). Drafting and serving the notice correctly is important. A landlord’s notice is known as a section 25 and a tenant’s is known as a section 26 request. A landlord will need to serve a counternotice in reply to a section 26 if it wants to obtain possession instead of granting a new lease. Other types of notices can also be served for achieving different purposes under the Act.

Top Tip

It is very important to take early legal advice when either serving a notice or if you have received one from a commercial property solicitor. Critical deadlines arise from the service of a notice. They are important to both landlords and tenants depending on the circumstances and if you are a business owner it is important to protect your business’s continuity and premises.

Boundary disputes

Boundary disputes can be a costly and disruptive issue for business owners, particularly if they involve shared spaces, access or land needed for business operations and continuity. Whether with neighbouring commercial properties or residential landowner’s these disputes can escalate quickly.

  • Most people do not wake up in the morning and think about starting a boundary dispute with their neighbour. More often than not, the positions of fences and hedges are not given much thought and can remain the same for decades.
  • One of the most common triggers for a boundary dispute is a neighbour’s plans to extend or develop their property. Often, the boundary will be disturbed during the process of the works, or one neighbour will challenge the boundary location in relation to the extension as a means of trying to stop the extension from being built.
  • In some cases, you might realise that your neighbour is in possession of land that you consider is within your title or vice versa. This situation might require the consideration of the law of adverse possession. Again, this realisation is not usually stumbled upon without some other triggering event (such as a neighbour’s extension or commercial development), which causes the boundary line to be brought into focus and considered.
  • Boundary disputes can be very expensive, mentally draining and often cause lasting damage to relations between neighbours. Boundary disputes are rarely resolved swiftly.

Top Tip

Boundary disputes can be complex and emotionally driven. Early legal advice, clear documentation and proactive communication are key to protecting your business interests and avoiding costly and prolonged conflict.

Rent arrears, tenant breaches and forfeiture

Rent arrears and other breaches of obligations under a lease can pose serious risks for both landlords and tenants in commercial property arrangements. For landlords, persistent non-payment or breaches may justify taking steps towards forfeiture (ending the lease early). However, this process is complex and must be handled carefully to avoid legal challenges or unintended consequences.

  • From time to time, a commercial tenant will fall into arrears with its rent or commit some other breach of the lease. As a landlord, you will want to understand your options.
  • It is not always in a landlord’s interest to react to a tenant’s breach by looking to terminate the lease (known as forfeiting). In a difficult market, this could leave a landlord with an empty property, saddled with business rates and keeping the property secure from squatters. There are alternative remedies which a landlord may wish to consider.
  • In some cases, a landlord will want to terminate or use the threat of forfeiture as leverage. However, some landlords do not know that their right to forfeit for a breach can be waived through their actions or those of their agents.
  • Equally, some landlords might not appreciate that there is a statutory notice which must be served before being able to forfeit for certain breaches or that the act of forfeiting the lease can give rise to offences being committed where the process known as peaceable re-entry is used incorrectly instead of issuing possession proceedings.
  • A landlord who forfeits unlawfully could face a claim for wrongful forfeiture and have to pay damages to its tenant.

Top Tip

It is sensible to seek advice on your options where a tenant is in breach and you are considering forfeiture. Forfeiture can be an effective remedy for a landlord if it is exercised properly but there are alternative remedies available which are often worth considering.

James Picknell, Lawyer, Partner, Real Estate Dispute Resolution, DMH Stallard

Our role is to support clients in navigating complex property related disputes – whether they involve commercial or residential property. Our commercial property solicitors will work closely with you to understand the issues and develop practical and effective strategies to resolve disputes efficiently.

 

James Picknell, Partner, Real Estate Dispute Resolution

Ready to take the next step?

Our commercial property solicitors represent property developers, local authorities, retailers, building contractors as well as investors, individual property owners, residential leaseholders and others. Our approach is simple: we work through the procedural red tape associated with real estate legislation from a commercial perspective to resolve real estate disputes and find solutions.

Contact an expert today

Google reviews

4.9
Extremely helpful initial consultation with clear and honest guidance borne of research into our specific situation
First class support from Michael Derrick on IHT issues and cross-border estate planning. Thanks, Michael!
This law firm assisted us with a complex family matter. They worked closely with us, their speed of response was excellent. They explain everything to us clearly and in an easy to understand manner. I willingly recommend them
Samantha & her team were amazing and massively helped us with our new house purchase. We would highly recommend these guys to anyone who wants a trouble free experience. Superb work. Thank you again!
We instructed DMH Stallard in relation to a difficult and emotionally challenging contentious probate matter. From the outset, the team provided calm, clear and practical advice, helping us navigate a complex process with professionalism and care.They were responsive, strategic and reassuring throughout, balancing strong legal guidance with a sensitive understanding of the personal issues involved. Their support helped us reach closure on a matter that had placed significant strain on our family.We are very grateful for their advice, persistence and professionalism, and would not hesitate to recommend DMH Stallard to anyone facing a complex probate dispute.
Samantha Smith provided us with such a professional and efficient service – much appreciated. Thanks Sam … you’re a huge asset to DMH Stallard 🙂
Very happy with the service provided by Maureen Murtagh. She was very thorough and professional, guiding us through three unsuccessful transactions and helping us to decide not to proceed, and ultimately a successful purchase of our dream house, which went very quickly and smoothly. Maureen was always approachable and it was very reassuring to have ready access to her expertise.
We worked with Samantha Smith on the sale of our property and she was brilliant – answered every question we had (no matter how many!) promptly and kept all communications regular and thorough. Thank you!
Samantha has helped us with three transactions in the last few months starting with the sale of our long term family house. We were very satisfied with the service she provided. Samantha was very straightforward to deal with and pragmatic in handling all three of our transactions. She was also realistic in setting expectations and made sure that she could deliver what she promised.We would happily recommend Samantha to others and plan to seek her assistance on a forthcoming transaction
Excellent Service from start to finish. Highly Recommended firm of solicitors.
This is the second time we have worked with Michael Daniel’s for a property transaction. He made the process so simple and I really appreciated the level of detail to his advice. We had the transaction done in less than 12 weeks! Thank you!
I had a very positive experience with Cathryn. She was knowledgeable, responsive, and explained legal issues clearly and calmly. I felt well-supported throughout the process and confident that my enquiry was being handled thoroughly and professionally.
Maureen Murtagh has been a great support helping us with the purchase of our property with a very professional and effective approach. Her ability to constantly follow up on issues and the fast response time made our experience with DMH Stallard very positive.
Stumbled upon DMH purely by chance and am very glad i I did. Their Team were extremely helpful, professional and always answered questions very promptly. Have already recommended to others who are also very pleased. Most of all they were always “on the front foot” and chasing the Vendors solicitor whose was not all all co-operative. I’d highly recommend.
Samantha Smith at DMH Stallard was brilliant in our house sale – she was knowledgable, efficient and went above and beyond to make the process as seamless as possible.
Rachel Osgood supported me with a tricky issue, and her approach was not only extremely professional and impactful. It was also very personable, and supported me well taking the more psychological factors of the issue into account as well. I highly recommend!
I chose to work with Tabitha on the purchase of our first home, and it was the best decision I made. As a first time buyer, it’s a really daunting process, and Tabitha was there at every step of the way to provide support and guidance. Tabitha is extremely efficient, determined and very easy to work with. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to purchase a house. I will absolutely get in touch with her if I need her services in the future.
Rachel was compassionate, knowledge and pragmatic, quickly grasping both the details and the context of the issue at hand. She provided a number of different options, with clear guidance as to the advantages and challenges of each. I felt very confident in her advice, her thoughtful approach and her steely spine !
So far, so good. We are very pleased with the person centred approach we received for a service some solicitors charge for. We have not been made to feel like we’re just another figure for their extortionate gain. Very calm professionals who show compassion and are attentive to detail. We have been particularly impressed with their responsiveness, next to none in our current experience. This has been reassuring. Highly recommended.
Tabitha was professional and quick in her responses. Her advice was sound and made for a quick resolution.
Samantha Smith at DMH Stallard was brilliant throughout. I felt very confident in her and she was a pleasure to work with. Thank you.
I have nothing but praise for Jenny Ray at DMH Stallard, specifically for her work on my behalf recently in connection with a rather sensitive and stressful family related legal matter, which required careful handling. Jenny is excellent at her job and she was always kind, understanding, thoughtful, highly professional and thorough throughout the whole time we worked together. I recommend her and the DMH Stallard company highly.
Sam Smith is an actual legend. We purchased our first home and had Sam do our conveyancing, it was the best decision ever. Sam was so efficient, quick and knowledgeable. 10/10 recommend
Amazing service through out. Samantha has been great. She explained everything and was very patient with our phone calls and emails. Not just with our sale and purchase but with selling my mother’s house which wasn’t straight forward.
We were very happy with Tabitha’s work on our conveyancing.Given we were keen to move quickly, Tabitha did everything she could to expedite all the paperwork. The property is a new-build, so there was additional paperwork to carry out.One constructive suggestion is around compliance.It seems they were only engaged a couple of days before Exchange, and because we had moved moneys around (to obtain best interest rates), they seemed to take a long time to tie up the numbers (albeit I was able to check all double entry movements in about 30 minutes), and a lot of effort at both ends.I would suggest compliance get involved at least a week before Exchange in case there are unexpected circumstances.
I have just finished a very helpful conversation with Cathryn where she helped me to understand some of issues related to estate administration. I found her to be professional and explained things in a way I could understand them. And also she sent me a summary of our conversation which will help as a reference point in the future. Thanks DMH Stallard.
incredibly helpful, professional and clear guidance, enabling an informed decision to be made on next steps. Can’t recommend highly enough!!
I reached out to Amber to help finish up a financial settlement that my previous solicitors had not concluded.Amber was a pleasure to deal with, excellent advice, and professionally and skillfully completed the prudes for me.Highly recommended.
Sam has been brilliant in acting on our behalf in selling our house. Our last move was 24 years ago and I hadn’t realised just how complicated conveyancing was nowadays! There were a few little issues throughout the journey, but Sam remained calm, dogged and professional throughout. Her calming influence really put my mind at rest no matter what hurdle or issue was thrown at us. I couldn’t recommend using Sam enough, 5 Star service. Thank you very much 🙂
Highly recommend DMH Stallard ! I worked with Tabitha who helped me with a very complex Transfer of Equity. She was very efficient, knowledgeable and at the same time friendly. She went above and beyond to complete the transfer. It was my pleasure to work with her.
I just completed on the sale of my house thanks to Samantha at DMH Stallard. I was very nervous as I live in the US and the house was back in the UK which complicated things however she made the process incredibly smooth and was always quick to respond to all my questions. I cannot recommend them highly enough. Costs were very reasonable too, especially for the excellent level of service and attention. Thank you SO much.
I had fantastic service from DMH Stallard. I used them for the conveyancing of my late mothers flat and it was a seamless transaction. My solicitor was Samantha Smith and I can’t recommend her highly enough. She was always on top of everything and I never had to chase her for anything. I highly recommend this company and Samantha in particular.
I had a Will problem caused by a different solicitor company. Cathryn and I discussed all the options in a lively, fun and detailed way. Cathryn then followed up with a perfect review of our conversation with cost estimates. I am very grateful
DMH were both professional and efficient in the administration of my deceased parents Estate & affairs, with clear and efficient support and directives throughout. Commercially aware with pro-active tax guidance, and prompt in all actions, in order to mitigate both time and expense. Personal service from Michael Derrick was exemplary and nothing was too much trouble. Took the weight off my shoulders during sad and stressful times.
Cathryn Culverhouse at DMS Stallard is an excellent lawyer. She heard and advised on my case; offered a range of ways forward, and represented me in a clear and straightfoward manner. I greatly appreciated Cathryn’s responsiveness and understanding approach to me as a client. The rest of the team at DMH Stallard are also very easy and friendly to work with.
I recieved a free 30 minute consultation with one of the partners, Cathryn Culverhouse, which was extremely informative and helpful, I would definitely recommend.
Always professional with a friendly touch, I would always recommend
We used Samantha Smith from DMH Stallard to act for us on the sale and purchase of our new home. I can only describe our extremely positive experience as ‘we were on the same team!’.As soon as our vendor’s solicitors sent anything, Samantha actioned it straight away. We never felt like we were the ones holding up the process and I never had to chase her for anything, she was so organised and professional throughout. As with many property transactions, things got really stressful towards the end (due to our seller trying to change dates unexpectedly which would have caused us to lose our buyer) and Samantha did everything she could to ensure a smooth and timely completion despite these challenges. I decided to also use DMH Stallard for the sale of my rental property and have already recommended them to friends and family. Thank you Samantha!!
Cathryn Culverhouse gave excellent advice, helping to put my mind at ease during a difficult and complicated time. She was patient, her knowledge extensive and by the end of our discussion I had a much clearer idea of my next course of action. I was surprised that the 30 minute consultation was also free of charge. Thank you again for your time.
Excellent service. Free half hour was invaluable, laid out clear options and helped me realise that this is a firm that I would want to handle our issue.
I approached DMH Stallard (Guildford office) late last year for assistance in a property matter of some complexity and was fortunate that Michael Daniels (ably assisted by Natalie Wicker-Freeman) took up the case on my behalf. Michael is very knowledgeable, providing sound advice and handling the process efficiently and effectively, bringing it to a successful conclusion within a fairly tight deadline. – and at a fair cost.I have worked with Stallards on several matters over the years and on that basis, plus this most recent experience, would have no hesitation in recommending the firm.
Very happy with our free consultation. Replied very quickly, offered advice to assist our situation, and didn’t want us to incur needless costs for advice or support which wasn’t required.
I had Amber Mathewson dealing my case after I failed with two previous solicitors. She did an excellent job with the case and it is finally resolved. Cannot recommend her enough!
Rachel Osgood at DMH Stallard is a sensitive, sensible, and truly empathizing family lawyer. She responded to my questions thoroughly, efficiently and in a supportive way. Her thoughtful approach made a significant difference in navigating a challenging time. Highly recommend!
Efficient, practical and thorough service.
Very efficient service. Very quick response to all communications. Would happily recommend.
js_loader

DISCLAIMER:

THIS INFORMATION IS FOR ILLUSTRATIVE PURPOSES AND IS NOT INTENDED TO AMOUNT TO LEGAL ADVICE ON WHICH RELIANCE SHOULD BE PLACED. WE, DMH STALLARD LLP, DISCLAIM ALL LIABILITY AND RESPONSIBILITY ARISING FROM ANY RELIANCE PLACED ON THIS INFORMATION. ANY RELIANCE ON THIS INFORMATION IS SOLELY AT YOUR RISK. The provision of this information does not create a business or professional services relationship. This information is not exhaustive and does not attempt to address every issue relevant to a particular situation. If you require advice on a specific legal issue, please contact a lawyer listed on our website, dmhstallard.com, or send an email to [email protected].