Our focus is you

Insurance cover is essential for many aspects of life, particularly if you are running a business. Thankfully many of us will never need to make a claim on our policies. However, if you do, disputes can arise with insurance companies and brokers over whether your claim should be accepted and early action at this stage can be key to securing a good result.

Disputes with insurance companies can affect individuals and businesses of all sizes, in every industry and sector. Our insurance disputes solicitors will work with you and your senior management team to understand your objectives and resolve the dispute.

More and more insurers are looking to find ways to decline cover fairly for claims made by their client, and by third parties against their clients. Our dispute lawyers regularly advise businesses about their disputes with their insurance companies, so we know that every case depends on its facts and the specific terms of the relevant insurance policy. We can advise you on the strength of your position and your options for challenging the insurer’s decision to decline cover. We can also advise upon the liability of insurance brokers in relation to claims arising from, for example, alleged deficiencies in the level of insurance cover obtained by the broker.

Our commercial dispute solicitors are ranked in the top legal directories that include Chambers and Partners (Band 2) and Legal 500 (Tier 2), whilst the firm is also recognised as a Leading Firm in both directories.

We have offices based in London and other locations across the South-east which include Gatwick and Crawley, Hassocks, Horsham, Brighton and Guildford.

Please note that visits to our office is by appointment only. If you require legal advice please contact one of our insurance dispute solicitors via our online enquiry form.

Stay connected, sign up for updates

Stay connected
Lucie J Thomas, Lawyer, Senior Associate, Dispute Resolution, DMH Stallard

Recent work

Sectors

Sectors
  • Banks and Financial Institutions (1)
  • Charities (1)
  • Construction and Engineering (2)
  • Manufacturing (1)
  • Professional Services (1)
  • Retail (1)

Shareholder dispute

Defending a claim in the London Court of International Arbitration regarding a dispute by a former shareholder who claimed his shares were unlawfully purchased from him by the company: £3.3m.

Fraud

A claim for fraud arising out of the dishonest diversion of business, clients and income by the Managing Director and others: £3,000,000.

High value claim

Defending a claim arising out of the design, construction, procurement, commissioning and installation of cooling units at data centre halls: £77m.

Joint venture agreement losses

A claim pursuant to personal guarantees for losses arising out of a Joint Venture Agreement: £7m.

Negligence claim against solicitors

Claim against solicitors for drafting errors in a Share Purchase Agreement: £4.5m.

High value risk mitigation

Assisting a national PLC with an ongoing project to address a myriad of financial and regulatory issues. We have worked with this client to identify and rectify these issues so as to achieve the client’s objectives in a cost-effective manner whilst successfully managing what could have been significant potential reputational risk for our client.

Dispute Resolution and Commercial Litigation Lawyers

High value director dispute

Acting for a luxury IT system and creative design company in a dispute involving the forced removal of a director and 50% shareholder for breach of fiduciary duties and shareholders’ agreement. The shareholder is aiming to recover its shares through a share buyback. The dispute, ongoing for over two years, has severely impacted our client’s business growth and development, complicated by the absence of a shareholders’ agreement and threats of unfair prejudice claims and attempts to wind-up the company.

Dispute Resolution and Commercial Litigation Lawyers

Defending complex enforcement action

Acting for a property construction and development company facing enforcement action over two loans totalling approximately £3.9m, secured by property and subject to multiple assignments. In response to the lender’s actions, we challenged the loans on various grounds, including regulatory compliance under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, asserting that they constitute unfair relationships under the Consumer Credit Act 1974, and disputing the validity of receiver appointments and default interest provisions, arguing that they are unenforceable as a penalty.

Construction and Engineering

Multi-angled shareholder dispute

Acting for a large care home group embroiled in a dispute with a departing employee/director who is also a shareholder and involved in competing businesses. The case involves complex issues of constructive dismissal, unfair prejudice, and refusal to relinquish shares, compounded by allegations of fraudulent misrepresentation and discussions around rescission of shareholder agreements. We are actively engaging in negotiations to force share buybacks and defend against expected High Court claims, which have disrupted the group’s growth plans, resulting in loss of management time and potential revenue.

Dispute Resolution and Commercial Litigation Lawyers

High value enforcement action

Representing an offshore lender involved in a joint loan of approximately £12m to two companies for land development in the North West of England, secured by legal charges and personal guarantees. After the companies defaulted, we assisted in various enforcement actions, including appointing receivers, and addressing issues with UN1 registrations from potential buyers. We are currently pursuing the directors under their personal guarantees to mitigate a substantial shortfall of over £6m for the lender.

Banking and Finance

Insights

Announcements

Firm views employee satisfaction as ‘key driver’ of success

DMH Stallard has reported exceptional levels of employee satisfaction, with 100% agreeing that the firm is a good place to work in latest survey.

28/09/2026

Insights

DMH Stallard advises BDX Group on ‘strategic acquisition’

DMH Stallard has advised BDX Group Ltd and Socrates Holdings Ltd on the successful acquisition of Socrates Imaging B.V. and Socrates Imaging Ltd.

24/09/2026

Insights

(Un)lawful information gathering: Baroness Lawrence v Associated Newspapers [2026]

unpacking the High Court’s dismissal of privacy claims arising from unlawful information gathering in Baroness Lawrence v Associated Newspapers [2026] EWHC 1637.

18/09/2026

Events

Right to work checks – Are you ready for 1 October 2026?

In this latest webinar, our Immigration team willl provide an overview of what is changing, what it means for your business, and how your commercial contracts and service arrangements may be impacted by the extended liabilities pertaining to third party workers.

DISCLAIMER:

THIS INFORMATION IS FOR ILLUSTRATIVE PURPOSES AND IS NOT INTENDED TO AMOUNT TO LEGAL ADVICE ON WHICH RELIANCE SHOULD BE PLACED. WE, DMH STALLARD LLP, DISCLAIM ALL LIABILITY AND RESPONSIBILITY ARISING FROM ANY RELIANCE PLACED ON THIS INFORMATION. ANY RELIANCE ON THIS INFORMATION IS SOLELY AT YOUR RISK. The provision of this information does not create a business or professional services relationship. This information is not exhaustive and does not attempt to address every issue relevant to a particular situation. If you require advice on a specific legal issue, please contact a lawyer listed on our website, dmhstallard.com, or send an email to [email protected].